Pages

Saturday, January 23, 2010

Indian Railways as a ISP!!

I type this blog post from a cybercafe premises at the chennai central railway station. Nothing too fancy about this facility run by IRCTC, except that the ISP (Internet Service Provider) here caught me by surprise.

My login page suggested that the service provider is a firm, known as 'Rail Wire'. Now, this was weird coz I didn't expect Indian railways to venture into the Internet services business. My first thoughts were that this is some branding exercise by the Indian railways and the actual services must be provided by another government firm like BSNL.

However, to my surprise, I found that the Railways actually had an interest in this business area and were operating for the last 10 years. An excerpt from the Rail wire website is provided below:

"RailWire is an initiative of the RailTel Corporation of India Limited (RailTel), a Government of India enterprise, with a mission to make available “ICT to Common Man” & “Internet, Education and Health Services to Masses”.

RailTel was formed in Sept 2000 with the objective of creating nation-wide broadband, telecom and multimedia network, to modernize Train Control Operation and Safety System of Indian Railways. RailTel's network passes through around 5,000 stations across the country, covering all central business districts, towns, cities, mini/major-metros.

RailTel is perhaps the only pan-India operating ISP who doesn’t have to slow down with the burden of legacy network pile-on. With several BSO’s and cellular operators availing RailTel’s NLD services, its initial market presence was felt as a “carrier’s carrier”. Subsequently, it started servicing several corporate business houses for their (VPN) connectivity requirements, and now, retail - with RailWire.

RailWire focuses on pure play broadband and VPN services. RailWire offers content & application driven network, great deal of flexibility and affordable pricing – all in one. RailWire aims to become a hub of local information and a tool for rendering communication, infotainment, education, health and community services to the masses."

Hmm...I should say an interesting business proposition but an equally interesting question is...why would Indian Railways want to venture into this non-core business when we have other state-runs businesses with whom railways can partner??

It makes some sense to assume that Railways started out with building its own network for it's requirements at remote station locations but the extension of this business plan to corporate and recently, to retail segments is puzzling.

How does this venture fit into the long term vision of railways? Further, how does railways plan to address the issues which will come up as it tries to scale this business. For example, as it scales this business, railways will directly compete with not just other private players but also government players in this domain who have ISP as their core business.

May be Railways is planning to take this venture the same route as IRCTC (it's catering and tourism division), but both are quite different in their proposition. IRCTC has a fixed mandate and operates only to extend tourism through the railway network and offer value-added catering services at railway stations and onboard trains.

Though I do see this service (rail wire) as a value-add from railways to it's passengers but again the same can be offered through partnerships and alliances.

Not clear on the business plan here....may be I will spend sometime during this trip thinking about this proposition and see if I can make some business sense.

Sunday, January 17, 2010

Quotable Quotes

"First they Ignore you,
then they Laugh at you,
then they Fight you,
then you Win"

~ Mahatma Gandhi

Monday, January 11, 2010

Stop listening to your customers!!


Customers are always right but they won’t always tell you the 'complete' truth...since they don’t know it themselves!!

Consider this live example set earlier this decade, Mr. Gupta used to own a reasonably-sized audio cassettes retail shop at one of Mumbai's western suburbs. Business was good with his shop boasting possession of every new Bollywood release in town. Customers were loyal and the sales folk were efficient. Until one day, Mr. Gupta quarterly sales report started showing a worrying revenue trend. Mr. Gupta checked all processes and control-points; everything looked good, still the numbers refused to look-up.

So, he adopted the age-old method, incidentally also taught at all B-schools (it’s another matter that he never went to one!), he started speaking to his customers...asked them what would they like at the store? There were plenty of responses which, he narrowed to a few categories:
  • Add old Bollywood titles to the collection
  • Make the collection more varied like including Indian classical titles
  • Pro-active sales folk who can suggest good music
  • More Promotional offers....bigger discounts
And many more...

Mr. Gupta liked the suggestions and started to work on them immediately. One month post-implementation of the turnaround plan, things were still stagnant...he was able to arrest the revenue slide but normalcy or growth was still not restored!!

So, what do you think went wrong!! Mr. Gupta did 'Exactly' as his customers said....and 'That' was the problem.

How??...let us analyze.

Typically, whenever you ask your customers for feedback, irrespective of the industry / product / services, the responses can be bucketed into pretty standard words....

"We want it better, bigger, cheaper or for longer term"

In my interactions with varied customers, I have seen customers asking for variants of the above few words with few operational improvements / enhancements thrown in.

But if we go solely by what our customers say then, our fate would soon be like Mr. Gupta's venture. Why??

"Because a customer will never tell you about introducing a "Fundamental" change in the way you do business or your product / service offerings"

In other words, a customer will never tell you about the 'shifts' which can challenge your very business model.

In Mr. Gupta's case, the culprit was the slow migration of customers to alternative products like Music CDs / online mp3 et al. Mr. Gupta was slow to realize this market shift....which gets us to the next question....So, how do you look out for the market shifts??

One of the definite ways to recognize potential market shifts is to keep a look-out for your competition products / services. By competition, it’s not just the big guys or folks at your level but even the 'Fringe' players....coz, it’s very often these niche / fringe / periphery players which bring in this market shifts.

You will find ample opportunities of this theory in practice:
  • Closure / downsizing of many traditional publishing houses owing to the new media
  • Movement from traditional broker houses to the world of online trading
  • Technologies such as Cloud computing which has changed the rules of the game especially in the SME sector

Many of these visible examples are from the technology sector but the same holds true for traditional sectors as well.

There will always be players in your sector which, will be working on the next 'wave' of things in your industry...they are the ones to watch out for; observe, learn and try to replicate if needed....or still better, collaborate.

In effect, in the longer term...its pays more to monitor your competition more than ask your customers for feedback...customers may suggest novel operational improvements but rarely will they guide you to the fundamental shifts.

Treat your customer as the 'King' but avoid taking all his words as the royal law :)